There are five churches located within the Borough and three located within close proximity of the Borough limits.
Christian & Missionary Alliance Church - 127 New Castle Street.
Neshannock Presbyterian Church - 330 W. Neshannock Avenue.
New Wilmington Presbyterian Church - 229 S. Market Street.
New Wilmington United Methodist Church - 125 S. Mercer Street.
Westminster College Chapel - Maple Street
Churches in Surrounding Area:
- Living Word Church - 269 Cowden Road, New Wilmington
- Maple Grove Mennonite Church - RD #5, New Castle
- New Life Baptist - St. Rt. 208, New Wilmington